Car Accidents

What Happens When Your Injury Claim Is Worth More Than the Policy Limits?

  • Available 24/7
  • Hablamos Español
  • No Fee Unless We Win
  • Free Consultation
November 6, 2026 5 minBy Saguaro Injury Law

The limit is the limit

A liability policy is a promise to pay for harm the policyholder causes, up to a stated amount. Arizona's required minimum is 25/50/15: $25,000 for injury to one person, $50,000 for all injuries in one crash, $15,000 for property damage. A hospital stay with surgery can pass $25,000 in days. When that happens, the at-fault driver's insurer will typically offer its full limit — and the question becomes where the rest comes from.

Your own underinsured motorist coverage

This is the coverage built for exactly this situation. Arizona law requires insurers to offer underinsured motorist coverage on every auto policy, and many drivers carry it without remembering they do. UIM pays the difference between what the at-fault driver's policy paid and what the claim is worth, up to your own UIM limit. In Arizona, whether UIM limits from more than one vehicle or policy can be combined — "stacking" — depends on the policy language, and in a serious injury it is worth reading every policy in the household.

Related: What Is Bodily Injury Liability Coverage in Arizona? (Explained Simply)

Other policies that may respond

The at-fault driver's umbrella policy, if one exists. An employer's commercial policy, if the driver was working. The vehicle owner's policy, if the driver was borrowing the car. A rideshare company's coverage, if a ride was in progress. A government entity, if a public vehicle or a road defect was involved. None of these are automatic; each has its own rules and some have short deadlines. The work of a serious-injury claim is largely the work of finding every policy that applies.

Related: What Is an Umbrella Policy? (The Extra Layer Most People Discover Too Late)

The driver's personal assets

In theory, a judgment larger than the insurance can be collected from the at-fault driver personally. In practice, most individual drivers who carry minimum limits do not have assets that make that realistic, and a claim built on that hope is usually a claim built on nothing. It is evaluated case by case.

The timing problem

A claim worth more than the limits is, by definition, a serious-injury claim — which means treatment is ongoing and the full value is not yet known. Accepting a policy-limits payment from the at-fault insurer before the UIM claim is positioned, or signing a release that is broader than it should be, can affect what the UIM carrier owes. The order in which these pieces are handled matters.

check your own coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

The other driver only has $25,000 in coverage and my bills are higher. What now?

The claim looks next to your own underinsured motorist coverage, UIM on other household policies, any umbrella policy the driver has, and any other responsible party. Finding every applicable policy is the core of the work.

Can I sue the driver personally for the rest?

A judgment above the insurance can be pursued against the driver, but for most drivers carrying minimum limits it is not a realistic source of recovery. It is evaluated case by case.

Should I accept the policy-limits offer right away?

Not before the rest of the claim is positioned. How and when a limits payment and release are handled can affect your UIM claim.

Injured in Arizona? Get a free case review.

If you've been injured in Arizona, contact Saguaro Injury Law for a free case review.

This article is for general informational purposes. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Want more Arizona injury guides in your Google feed?