The letter sounds harmless: the insurer has "scheduled an independent medical examination to evaluate your claim." Here's what's actually happening.
What an IME is. A physician chosen and compensated by the insurance company examines you once — often briefly — then writes a report. In liability claims, these typically appear once a lawsuit is filed, where court rules allow the defense a medical examination. In some first-party contexts (like certain policy benefits), your own policy's cooperation clauses may require an exam. Which situation you're in determines whether and how you must attend — a question for your lawyer, not the adjuster.
Why "independent" is generous. An examiner who derives regular income from insurer referrals has a familiar pattern: injuries are "resolved," ongoing symptoms are "subjective," treatment was "excessive," and anything persistent is "degenerative and pre-existing." Not every IME doctor writes that report — but the incentive structure is what it is, and you should walk in knowing it.
How to handle an IME. Be honest, be consistent, and volunteer nothing beyond what's asked. Know your own history — the examiner has read every record, and inconsistency is the report's favorite word. Don't exaggerate: overstated symptoms discredit real ones. Note the appointment's actual length and what was examined; a four-minute exam that produces a four-page opinion is useful to know about. Where appropriate, your lawyer can set conditions in advance.
Countering a bad IME report. Your treating physicians — who have seen you across months, not minutes — are the answer. Consistent treatment records, completed referrals, and documented symptom progression outweigh a single adversarial snapshot far more often than insurers hope. A pre-existing-condition opinion runs into Arizona's recognition that aggravating an existing condition is itself compensable.
Saguaro Injury Law handles Arizona injury claims on contingency — you pay nothing unless we win. Free consultations any hour, in English or Spanish. Call (602) 217-0000.
