Common reasons insurers deny claims
- A policy exclusion the insurer says applies
- Coverage limits that have been exhausted
- Late notice of the claim
- A dispute about whether the loss happened the way you described
- A dispute about whether treatment was reasonable or necessary
- An alleged misrepresentation on the application
- A lapsed or canceled policy
Some of these are legitimate. Many involve an interpretation of the policy or the facts that can be challenged.
The first steps after a denial
- Get the denial in writing, with the specific policy provisions and reasons cited.
- Read the full policy — the declarations page, the provisions the insurer cited, the definitions and the exclusions — and compare them to the denial.
- Keep a record of every call, letter and email, including names and dates.
- Note the appeal deadline in the denial letter and do not miss it.
- Do not ignore the denial hoping it resolves itself. Deadlines keep running.
Path 1: internal appeal
Most policies provide an internal appeal. A good appeal is written, references the denial letter, addresses each stated reason with documents and facts, and asks for reconsideration. Health plans have additional appeal and external-review rights set by law, and employer-sponsored health plans are governed by federal rules — those are separate processes with their own deadlines.
Path 2: a complaint to the Arizona Department of Insurance and Financial Institutions
Arizona's unfair claim settlement practices statute, A.R.S. § 20-461, lists conduct insurers may not engage in as a general business practice — for example, misrepresenting policy provisions, failing to act promptly on claim communications, refusing to pay claims without a reasonable investigation, and not attempting in good faith to settle claims where liability is reasonably clear. The statute provides an administrative remedy through the Department, not a private lawsuit; it expressly states that it does not create a private right of action. A complaint can be filed with the Department, which can investigate and take action against the insurer.
Path 3: a lawsuit for breach of contract and bad faith
If the policy covers the loss and the insurer did not pay, a breach-of-contract claim seeks what the policy owes. Arizona also recognizes a separate tort claim for insurance bad faith: the Arizona Supreme Court held in Noble v. National American Life Insurance Co. (1981) that an insurer has a duty of good faith in dealing with its insured on a claim, and that a violation of that duty is a tort. A bad-faith claim turns on whether the insurer denied, failed to process or failed to pay a claim without a reasonable basis — not on an honest disagreement about coverage.
Deadlines for contract and tort claims differ, and they run from the denial. An attorney should calculate them for your situation.
When a denial may be correct
Not every denial is wrong. A loss that falls squarely within a clear exclusion, limits that have truly been paid out, or a material misrepresentation on the application can support a legitimate denial. Part of the first consultation is a candid read on which category your denial falls into.
This article is general legal information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Saguaro Injury Law offers free consultations 24/7 in English and Spanish at (602) 217-0000.
