Which parts of a settlement are treated as community property?
The parts of a settlement that compensate the community — lost wages during the marriage, medical bills paid from community funds — have generally been treated as community property, because those losses were the couple's losses. The parts that compensate the injured person personally — pain and suffering, the loss of a bodily function, the personal effects of the injury — have generally been treated as that spouse's separate property, because the injury happened to that person's body. That distinction matters in two situations. In a divorce, it affects how a settlement, or the assets bought with it, get divided.
And in a wrongful death claim after a spouse's passing, it affects how the recovery is characterized.
Why is the characterization hard after the fact?
The practical difficulty is that most settlements arrive as one number without a breakdown. Separating the personal portion from the community portion after the fact can be difficult, which is why the characterization is sometimes addressed in the settlement documents themselves, or why some people keep settlement funds in a separate account rather than commingling them with joint money. A few things worth saying plainly. The injured spouse's claim is their claim; the other spouse may have a related claim of their own for the loss of the injured spouse's companionship and support, called loss of consortium, which is separate.
Who should answer the question in a divorce?
The characterization question is one for a family-law professional when a divorce is involved, and the injury firm's role is to document the components of the settlement clearly so that question can be answered later. If you're receiving a settlement and wondering how it fits with your marriage, that's a fair thing to ask about.
Saguaro Injury Law handles Arizona injury claims on contingency — you pay nothing unless we win. Free consultations any hour, in English or Spanish. Call (602) 217-0000.
