Making an injury claim puts your health at issue. How much of it — that's the fight worth understanding.
What insurers legitimately need. Records documenting the injuries you claim: the ER visit, the imaging, the orthopedic consults, the therapy notes, the bills. Relevant prior history is also fair game — if you're claiming a back injury, records showing your back's condition before the crash bear on causation and on aggravation (which Arizona law compensates — see our pre-existing condition explainer).
Related: How Does a Personal Injury Lawyer Document Your Treatment? (Why the File Decides the Case)
The blanket authorization trick. Early in a claim, adjusters routinely send a medical authorization covering all providers, all conditions, all time. Signing it hands over your complete history — mental health care, unrelated conditions, decades of appointments — to people searching for anything to recharacterize your injury. You are not required to sign it to pursue a claim. The honest rule: relevance is the boundary, and scope is negotiable.
How disclosure actually works when represented. Your attorney collects your records, reviews them, and produces what's relevant with the demand. If litigation comes, discovery rules govern — broader than negotiation, but still bounded by relevance and subject to court supervision and protective orders. Either way, someone who represents you is deciding scope, instead of a records vendor with a blanket form.
Privacy inside the claim. Records produced in a claim go to the insurer's file and its reviewers — including any retained examiner (see our IME guide). They don't become public. In litigation, sensitive material can be filed under seal or governed by protective orders.
What you should do. Don't sign medical authorizations from the other side's insurer before getting advice. Do keep treating and keep your own copies — your portal access is faster than records requests. And be accurate with providers: the record is the claim.
Saguaro Injury Law handles Arizona injury claims on contingency — you pay nothing unless we win. Free consultations any hour, in English or Spanish. Call (602) 217-0000.
