"You had degenerative disc disease anyway." If an adjuster has said something like this to you, know two things: it's their favorite argument, and Arizona law doesn't say what they're implying.
The rule: defendants take you as they find you. The eggshell plaintiff principle is bedrock negligence law: a negligent driver is responsible for the harm actually caused to the actual person they hit — even if a healthier person would have fared better. Prior vulnerability is not a defense.
Aggravation is compensable. The legally precise framing: you recover for the worsening. If your knee was arthritic but functional, and post-crash it requires replacement, the claim is for that change — the new treatment, the new limitations, the new pain. What you can't recover for is the part of your condition that existed anyway. Drawing that line is where these claims are won and lost.
Baseline evidence is your friend, not your enemy. Counterintuitive but true: your prior records help. They establish precisely what your condition was before — how often you treated, what you could do, what imaging showed. The starker the before-and-after, the stronger the aggravation claim. This is why hiding history is catastrophic: concealment converts a winnable aggravation claim into a credibility problem. Disclose, contextualize, win.
"Degenerative findings" on imaging. Here's the insurers' quiet secret: age-related findings on MRIs are near-universal in adults — many symptom-free. A radiologist noting degeneration doesn't establish your pain predated the crash. The medical question is symptomatic change: when did pain begin, what could you do before versus after. Treating physicians who can speak to that trajectory beat a records-review opinion (and if an IME claims otherwise, see our IME guide).
Related: Older Adults After a Crash — Why "Minor" Injuries Aren't Always Minor
Practical moves. Be complete with your attorney about medical history — surprises are the only unmanageable thing. Describe your pre-crash function concretely to doctors. Keep treating consistently (gaps hurt aggravation claims doubly).
Saguaro Injury Law handles Arizona injury claims on contingency — you pay nothing unless we win. Free consultations any hour, in English or Spanish. Call (602) 217-0000.
