Who is at fault in a freeway sideswipe?
The rule is simple: a driver changing lanes has to make sure the lane is clear and signal before moving. The driver who left their lane is generally the one at fault. The dispute is about which driver that was. Each driver tends to believe they were holding their lane and the other one drifted. Without evidence, insurers are left with two honest, opposite accounts — and under Arizona's pure comparative fault rule, that often ends in a split, with each driver assigned a share and each claim reduced accordingly.
The evidence that breaks the tie is specific to sideswipes.
What evidence breaks the tie in a sideswipe?
Damage patterns: the location and direction of scrapes on each vehicle often show which one was moving laterally. Lane position after the crash. Witnesses, particularly drivers behind the two vehicles who saw the movement. Dashcam footage, which is decisive when it exists. And the freeway cameras ADOT operates, whose footage is sometimes available if requested quickly. Some sideswipes have a clearer story: a driver merging from an on-ramp into occupied space, a driver cutting across two lanes for an exit, a truck whose length put part of it in the next lane during a lane change.
What if a commercial truck was involved?
Commercial trucks add a layer — their blind spots are large, and a truck driver who changed lanes into a car they couldn't see may be responsible, and the carrier's records may matter. The injuries in sideswipes range from minor to serious, because a sideswipe at freeway speed can send a vehicle into a barrier or another lane. The claim follows the usual path — prompt evaluation, consistent treatment, a record.
Saguaro Injury Law handles Arizona injury claims on contingency — you pay nothing unless we win. Free consultations any hour, in English or Spanish. Call (602) 217-0000.
