What subrogation is
When a health insurer pays for treatment after a crash and the injured person later recovers money from the at-fault driver, the insurer in many states has a right to be repaid from that recovery. That right — stepping into the injured person's shoes to recover what it paid — is subrogation, and a related contractual version is called a reimbursement claim. In much of the country it is a routine deduction from a settlement.
Arizona's rule is different
Arizona courts have held for decades that a cause of action for personal injury cannot be assigned, and that subrogation of such a claim amounts to an assignment — so it is not permitted. The Arizona Supreme Court's 1978 decision in Allstate v. Druke is the foundation, and the Court of Appeals has repeatedly restated that "Arizona law generally forbids subrogation in personal injury cases." The practical effect: a fully insured private health plan governed by Arizona law generally cannot take a share of an injury settlement to recoup what it paid, even if the policy contains reimbursement language.
The exceptions, and they are significant
Federal law overrides Arizona's rule in several situations. Self-funded ERISA employer health plans — common at large employers — can enforce reimbursement provisions under federal law. Medicare has a statutory right of reimbursement that is handled as part of every settlement involving a Medicare beneficiary, and Medicare Advantage plans have been held to share that right. Federal employee health plans were held in 2016 to be able to enforce reimbursement clauses as well. On the state side, AHCCCS (Arizona Medicaid) has statutory recovery rights, and hospitals and licensed providers can record statutory liens under A.R.S. § 33-931 for unpaid charges.
Related: How Long Does It Take to Resolve Medical Liens After a Settlement?
Why "what kind of plan" is the whole question
Two people with the same injury and the same settlement can end up with very different net recoveries depending on whether their health coverage was a fully insured plan (Arizona rule usually applies), a self-funded employer plan (ERISA usually applies), or Medicare or AHCCCS. Identifying the plan type early — usually from the plan documents, not the insurance card — is one of the first things a thorough office does, because it changes what the settlement needs to cover.
Related: Who Gets Paid First Out of a Settlement? (The Order, Explained)
Auto insurance is handled separately
Arizona's statute does allow a UM/UIM insurer to seek recovery from an uninsured driver for what it paid, and it requires a medical payments insurer to compromise any reimbursement claim in a fair and equitable manner. Those are narrower, statute-based rules and are not the same as the health-insurance question above.
