The exclusive remedy rule
A.R.S. § 23-1022(A) provides that the right to workers' compensation is the exclusive remedy against the employer and against co-employees acting within the scope of their employment. That rule is why the ordinary negligence case — an unsafe condition, inadequate training, a missing guard — stays inside the workers' comp system.
Exception 1: wilful misconduct by the employer
Section 23-1022 preserves a lawsuit where the injury is caused by the employer's wilful misconduct. The statute defines wilful misconduct narrowly: "an act done knowingly and purposely with the direct object of injuring another," and it must be the personal act of the employer (or a partner, or an elective officer of a corporation) showing a wilful disregard of the life, limb or bodily safety of employees. Negligence, even gross negligence or a safety violation, does not meet that definition. When it applies, the employee may either claim compensation or sue for damages.
Exception 2: the employer failed to carry required coverage
A.R.S. § 23-907 addresses employers who are required to secure workers' compensation and fail to do so. Such an employer is not entitled to the protections of the workers' compensation chapter during the period of noncompliance and is liable in a civil action. In that action the employer cannot raise the defenses of assumption of risk or contributory negligence, and proof of the injury is prima facie evidence of the employer's negligence. The injured employee may instead apply to the Industrial Commission for compensation, which is paid from a special fund and then collected from the employer.
Whether an employer was required to carry coverage, and whether it did, can be checked with the Industrial Commission of Arizona. Do not assume coverage exists.
Exception 3: the injury is not a work injury
Workers' compensation covers injuries arising out of and in the course of employment. An injury that happened on company premises but had nothing to do with work — for example, during a purely personal activity or an ordinary commute — may not be covered, in which case the exclusive remedy rule does not apply and ordinary negligence law does. Whether a specific injury is work-related is often disputed and should be evaluated by an attorney.
Exception 4: a third party caused the injury
This is by far the most common path to a lawsuit. Under A.R.S. § 23-1023, an employee injured by the negligence or wrong of a person not in the same employ may pursue a claim against that person while also receiving workers' comp benefits. Other drivers, other contractors on a job site, property owners, and manufacturers of defective equipment are typical third parties. The carrier has a lien on the recovery for benefits paid, and the third-party action must be brought within one year or the claim is deemed assigned to the carrier. See our guide to third-party claims in Arizona workers' comp cases for the details.
Related claims that run alongside workers' comp
Some employer conduct supports claims that are separate from the injury itself — for example, a termination in retaliation for exercising workers' compensation rights, which A.R.S. § 23-1501 addresses. Those claims proceed in addition to, not instead of, the compensation claim.
Practical steps
- Report the injury and file the workers' comp claim promptly; the claim must be filed within one year under A.R.S. § 23-1061(A)
- Get and follow medical treatment, and keep every record
- Photograph the scene and equipment and collect witness names before anything changes
- Identify everyone who may have contributed: other companies, equipment makers, property owners
- Do not sign releases or give recorded statements to an insurer without legal review
- Talk to an attorney about whether any exception or any third-party claim applies
This article is general legal information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Saguaro Injury Law offers free consultations 24/7 in English and Spanish at (602) 217-0000. For help with a work injury claim, see our Phoenix workers' compensation lawyer page.
