Practice Areas

Does a Wrongful Death Claim Affect the Criminal Case? (Two Separate Tracks, Explained Gently)

  • Available 24/7
  • Hablamos Español
  • No Fee Unless We Win
  • Free Consultation
November 12, 2026 3 minBy Saguaro Injury Law

Does a wrongful death claim affect the criminal case? This is offered gently, for families asking a question that comes up whenever a death involves a driver who may be charged. The short answer is that the two run on separate tracks, and one doesn't control the other. The criminal case belongs to the state. Prosecutors decide whether to charge the driver, the charges are proven to a high standard, and the outcome is a conviction, a plea, or an acquittal. The family may have rights in that process as victims — to be informed, to be present, to be heard — but the family isn't a party to it and doesn't direct it.

The civil claim belongs to the family. Arizona law allows certain family members — generally a surviving spouse, children, and parents — to bring a wrongful death claim for their own losses, against the responsible driver's insurance. It's proven to a lower standard than a criminal case, it's about compensation rather than punishment, and it proceeds whether or not charges are filed. A few ways the tracks touch.

How can a conviction affect the civil claim?

A conviction or a guilty plea can be used as evidence in the civil claim, which can simplify the fault question. An acquittal doesn't end the civil claim, because the standards are different — a driver found not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt can still be found responsible by the civil standard. The civil claim sometimes waits for parts of the criminal case to conclude, for practical reasons: witness availability, access to the investigation file. And restitution ordered in a criminal case may be credited against what's recovered in the civil claim, so the two are coordinated at the end.

Does pursuing the civil claim interfere with the prosecution?

Families often ask whether pursuing the civil claim would interfere with the prosecution. It doesn't. The civil claim is the family's own path, and the two can proceed together with care. Arizona generally gives a family two years to bring a wrongful death claim, and nothing about it needs to be decided while the criminal case is in its early stages.

Saguaro Injury Law handles Arizona injury claims on contingency — you pay nothing unless we win. Free consultations any hour, in English or Spanish. Call (602) 217-0000.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does pursuing the civil claim interfere with the prosecution?

Families often ask whether pursuing the civil claim would interfere with the prosecution. It doesn't. The civil claim is the family's own path, and the two can proceed together with care.

Does an acquittal end the civil claim?

An acquittal doesn't end the civil claim, because the standards are different — a driver found not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt can still be found responsible by the civil standard.

How can a conviction affect the civil claim?

A conviction or a guilty plea can be used as evidence in the civil claim, which can simplify the fault question.

Injured in Arizona? Get a free case review.

If you've been injured in Arizona, contact Saguaro Injury Law for a free case review.

This article is for general informational purposes. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Want more Arizona injury guides in your Google feed?