The two systems
Roughly a dozen states use a "no-fault" system, in which each driver's own insurance pays their medical bills after a crash regardless of who caused it, through required personal injury protection (PIP) coverage, and lawsuits against the other driver are limited to serious injuries. Everywhere else — including Arizona — uses the traditional at-fault, or tort, system: the person who caused the crash pays for the harm, through their liability insurance.
How Arizona's at-fault system works
Every Arizona driver is required to carry liability coverage of at least 25/50/15. When a crash happens, fault is determined from the evidence — the crash report, statements, photographs, physical damage — and the at-fault driver's insurer is responsible for the injured person's medical expenses, lost income, and other damages up to the policy limit. If fault is shared, Arizona's pure comparative fault rule assigns each driver a percentage, and each recovery is reduced by that driver's own share. There is no threshold of injury severity required to make a claim.
Where the confusion comes from
Three things make people wonder whether Arizona is no-fault. First, medical payments coverage: Arizona insurers offer MedPay, which pays early medical bills regardless of fault and functions a little like PIP, but it is optional and does not change who is ultimately responsible. Second, uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage: these are claims made on your own policy, which can feel like a no-fault process, but they exist precisely because the at-fault driver could not pay. Third, people who move to Arizona from no-fault states like Florida or Michigan bring their expectations with them.
What it means for an injured person
Because Arizona is at-fault, proving who caused the crash is the foundation of every claim. That is why the first days after a collision — the crash report, photographs, witness information, a prompt medical evaluation — matter so much, and why a dispute about fault is a dispute about the whole claim rather than a side issue.
